Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gary D. Grossman's avatar

Thanks for that great display of humanity. Actually I know two families who lost children in the massacre, so in fact it is about me, my relatives and friends. In contrast to your mistaken assertion (purposeful?) that all that's being said is "Israel, we charge you with genocide" there are well documented antisemitic actions that have occurred on campuses see today's Atlantic https://www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2023/11/campus-anti-semitism-hamas-war/675991/ and I could quote or provide links to other articles such as the Jerusalem Post https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/antisemitism/article-770475 . I do notice that you mention nothing about the massacre and kidnapping of Jewish children, so apparently you have no concerns about those acts, or the Hamas charter which calls for Jewish genocide. And please, you know nothing of me, what training I've had in the conflict, what I've experienced, or done, so don't bother telling me what I should and shouldn't care about and stop your ad hominem attacks. Human rights work both ways. In fact I am very concerned about civilian casualties in Gaza and mourn the fact that Hamas uses civilians as shields as documented in this NATO report https://stratcomcoe.org/.../pfiles/hamas_human_shields.pdf . "A broad swathe..." of Germans demanded the extinction of the Jews, so arguments about popular opinion are particularly irrelevant to issues of human rights.

Gary D. Grossman's avatar

As an older person of the Jewish faith, whose grandparents left Russia because family members were killed in pogroms, and as someone who lost five family members in the Holocaust, I can't believe we've come to this. Graduate students ripping down posters of kidnapped kids, students chanting kill the Jews, and lit mag folks insisting it's just about colonialism. It feels very much like Germany in 1936. The saddest thing is so few of these protestors and BDS folks actually know much about the history of the conflict, because, well, it's not really about facts is it? And deep down, it's not really about Israel either, it's just about that millennia old racism called antisemitism.

49 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?