Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Paul Adams's avatar

How touching and provocative, Hema's piece on writing and death. And how universal the struggle to comprehend it, come to terms with it, and somehow and in some way accept it.

On a whim, I Googled "literary obsession with death;" the search returned many hundreds of responses. One posed most of the questions we've all asked ourselves, particularly, but not exclusively, after having "lost" someone dear to us: "Why are we here? What is the point of life? Why do we die? What happens when we die? Do we cease to exist? Do we keep on living somehow? If we keep on living, what will we be doing? Will eternity be all the same? What am I supposed to be doing while I’m alive? Did I come from someplace before this life? These questions, and many more like it, have plagued [writers], as well as many others, for ages. And the body of poetry we have today that surrounds the issue has evidenced that fact."

True enough. I recall having been asked by a student years ago when I was teaching English at a Connecticut high school why writers were so obsessed by death. My response was probably inadequate, but I think now that the appropriate response might be, "Because it's one of only a handful of absolutely 'ultimate' questions." Unfortunately, the post from which I quoted above goes on to make the patently absurd assertion that Mormonism provides all the answers, or more directly THE answer. Alas, neither it, nor any other religion accomplishes that daunting task.

Writers don't either, but the variety of their approaches to it, the universality of their interest and curiosity about it, the depth of the ache invoked in them by it, and (often but not always) the height of the affirmation of life and happiness inspired by it, have helped me and seemingly many others accommodate ourselves -- which I think is all we can do -- to the reality and inevitability of it.

How beautifully and poignantly the dilemma of death and loss was put by Hopkins in the last several insightful lines of "Spring and Fall:"

". . .

Now no matter, child, the name:

Sórrow’s spríngs áre the same.

Nor mouth had, no nor mind, expressed

What heart heard of, ghost guessed:

It ís the blight man was born for,

It is Margaret you mourn for."

Expand full comment
Tracie Adams's avatar

Yesterday I watched the hummingbirds at the feeder, and I cried. My best friend in the whole world died from a brain tumor two years ago. I can’t see spring flowers or watch birds from my porch without thinking of her. I’d love to tell you that time takes the sting out of grief, but I think it’s more like developing a chronic illness that we learn to live with, and we do. We adapt our lives to make room for the absence. It changes us. I would especially like to tell you that you are doing great. Give yourself as much grace as you would give someone you love, your sister for instance. If she were grieving like you are, feeling a bit lost and off balance , you would love her tenderly through it. Love yourself like that. The Bible tells us that there is a season for everything, a time to rejoice and a time to grieve. This is that time. You inspired and encouraged my heart with your words. You’re doing great.

Expand full comment
37 more comments...

No posts