22 Comments

this is the best writing I have yet seen oern the publishing industry of the United State's long and utterly jingoistic approach to the literatures of the world reducing millions of people's choice to a long history of white writers, women and men, some brilliant such as Virginia Woolf, Thomas Hardy,, Ernest Hebert, Muriel Rukeyser, and leaving out such wondrous and thunderous giants as Mahmoud Darwish, Pablo Neruda, Elsa Morante, Isabel Allende, Arundahti Roy, and so many others, depriving US reader of oceans of insight and beauty. But this is what happens in a capitalist society that mistakes greed for gifts and gluttony for glory and gives major awards to the garrulous , the puny, and the human receptacles of potential endless natural gas, but one will not understand the world and all our global neighbors without reading such amazing works such as Victor Serge's The Case of Comrade Tulayev about resilience in the maw of mass terror, or Jorge Amado's astonishingly delightful The Tent of Miracles with an entirely new approach to education, or Oran Pamuk's stupendous lovemystery My Name Is Red, or Ousmane Sembene's epic tale of Senegalese railroad workers on a national strike on a drive against French Imperialism. Or how about the meteoric suurealism of the poetry of Vi Khi Nao, Linh Dinh, and Mai Der Vang run down walk to get these comets but get pants with big pockets so you can the poems of Doug Kearneye, Patricia Smth and Tyehimba Jess and others from Cave Canem and Kundian, an Asian American group. or SPIN THEGLOBE AND FIND A DEEPER PART Of GORGEOUS ADVENTURe

Expand full comment

When I reviewed crime fiction for the Detroit Free Press, I tried my best to include translated crime fiction to broaden possibilities for my readers.

Expand full comment

This is fantastic. Thank you so much!

Expand full comment

Ann Morgan's book on the challenges of meeting her goal of reading a book from every corner of the globe is a book worth reading. In America Morgan's book is given the title "The World Between Two Covers". She continues to maintain and add new books the blog she started to celebrate her round-the-world reading: https://ayearofreadingtheworld.com

Expand full comment

Well done! When I was pitching Mónica Lavín's Sor Juana novel, I heard exactly what you mention here: no one knows who she is. Your "translators get no respect" discussion is pertinent and still of the moment, I'm afraid. In the introductory class on translation I teach—grad school creative writing—many come in thinking the equivalent of, "but you just get Google to translate it, right?"

Expand full comment

Well said. 'When readers don’t have a chance to draw parallels between their own needs, dreams, and realities and those of people elsewhere, they are blinded to ways of seeing that are distinct from their own.' This captures in a nutshell the monoculture that dominates US publishing, where the willfully blind choose what we see.

Expand full comment
Apr 20, 2023Liked by D. P. Snyder

Great questions and exposure in general. Much for me to digest, ruminate upon, understand, and, hopefully – as a literary translator since the 1970s – to act upon. Here's a backgrounder I wrote in 2008 adding some historical continuity to the conversation

https://www.pastemagazine.com/article/lost-and-found

Expand full comment

Wonderful and persuasive! Perhaps anything translated is perceived as "literary," which while high praise for some is the kiss of death for publishers.

Expand full comment

I notice this lack of interest in crediting translators with some of the books I own. In The Collected Short Stories of Satyajit Ray, originally in Bengali, the publisher, The Penguin Ray Library, only mentions the translator, Gopa Majumdar, on the reverse of the title page, not on the cover.

Gabriel García Márquez’ Love in the Time of Cholera, published by Alfred A. Knopf, credits Edith Grossman on the inside title page but not on the front cover.

It’s only with factual books such as Bushido: The Way of the Samurai based on the Hagakure by Tsunetomo Yamamoto that a publisher like Square One Classics mentions translator Minoru Tanaka on the front cover. Literary works don’t seem to merit the same treatment.

This seems to not only indicate a preference for ‘in’ topics at the expense of literary works but also suggests an inclination towards pragmatic versus creative writing, indicative of US culture.

Expand full comment
Apr 20, 2023·edited Apr 20, 2023Liked by D. P. Snyder

3% is a shocking number - I had no idea it was that low. The fact that we don't have access to so many stories that aren't anglo keeps us small and narrow and blind.

Expand full comment
Apr 20, 2023Liked by D. P. Snyder

Very thorough and thoughtful assessment. I'm just discovering some of the magazines you mentioned.

Expand full comment